Author Archives: Matthew Robinson

Catnip, Plato and Crowley

Warning: The following post will get dorky.

I’ve belabored Crowley’s leadership ambitions long enough. But I failed to ask myself an important question first: why would he want to climb the ladder anyway? As a philosophy major in undergrad, I remember reading about the nature of leadership in Plato’s Republic – (told you it’d get dorky).

The book is a thought experiment about developing the utopian city. In another words, it’s a classic that few read cover to cover – I haven’t – Sparknotes is like catnip for procrastinators.

Anyway, one section of the book explains how the very people who want leadership positions are the ones who shouldn’t be leading.

“The state in which the rulers are most reluctant to govern is always the best and most quietly governed, and the state in which they are most eager, the worst.”

Think high school student government. David Foster Wallace did a good job summing up the personality type.

Think back to the sort of kids in high school or college who were into running for student office: dweeby, overgroomed, obsequious to authority, ambitious in a sad way. Eager to play the Game. The kind of kids other kids would want to beat up if it didn’t seem so pointless and dull.

Although Crowley would have been difficult to beat up at 6’4,’’ he is the student government-type; he’s been in office since he was 24.

Maybe Crowley isn’t after personal gain entirely, but he sees the chance to do some good and get paid to do it. A member of Congress makes $169,000, and state assembly members make around $80,000.

Nevermind free parking, great health insurance, or the 16 weeks off they get each year. They were scheduled to be in session only 137 days last year.

Granted, their time off is considered “work-breaks” or “home-district periods,” where they meet constituents. I agree, meeting with the public is probably about as fun as a day at the DMV.

But these are the perks the public knows of, it’s only through scandal do we see what else they get.

Farts, Sycophants and New York’s 7th District

After trying to find clips of the White House correspondents’ dinner Saturday night, I asked myself, “Why do I care?” or more impolitely, “Who gives a shit?”

I started thinking, none of my friends probably even know it’s happening (beside my classmates reading this) or what it is – my mom wouldn’t. It certainly won’t affect me.

The whole affair seems like TMZ, politics and a high school prom put together.

The Sunday morning shows will probably say Obama snubbed so and so, or that he shouldn’t have attended and should have been in Louisiana and that this is his Katrina.

This is what’s wrong with media coverage. They track missteps, farts, and sycophants.

Technology isn’t helping this sound bite coverage. We’re all a little more scatterbrained. Have you seen anyone under the age of 30 in line at Starbucks, not looking at their phone (myself included)? By 2015, 140 characters will be the new short story. Frgt vwls.

Bill O’Reilly has some 3.5 million views a night – far and above the leader – while “Dancing with the Stars” has 23 million viewers. I think there’s a market to be had.

We can connect with 5th grade friends on Facebook, but can’t get people interested in politics.

After Saturday night’s fanfare, I know my trips from school back to the Bronx won’t change. I’ll see the same people begging for money, the same workers dozing off after too many hours, and a few of them quenching the thirst of a better life with a Budweiser.

Joe Crowley’s district – where I live – is still one of poorest in the country. He’s not responsible for decades of destitution, but who is?

Crowley will win in November. He may even grab a top leadership post as well. But even a well-positioned Congressman can only do so much.

Just walk through Charlie Rangel’s district.

Crowley Silent on Ariz Immigration Law

Arizona just passed a strict new immigration legislation. The law allows police to question people about their immigration status if they suspect someone is in the country illegally.

Crowley pushed for reform last summer when he, and 111 Democrats, asked President Obama to make the issue a priority.

Crowley issued no press release in response to the Arizona law. No public rebuke. No nothing.

Crowley was the first one to sign the bill last summer, and right next to his name was Luis Gutierrez, the 9-term Democrat from Illinois. Gutierrez had no problem making noise this week.

“Where is the Justice Department? Here is an injustice against the basic rights. Where is the administration of Barack Obama and his Justice department?” said Gutierrez, according to MSNBC

Gutierrez, surprisingly, was one of Obama’s first supporters – even when most hispanics were supporting Hilary Clinton – when he decided to run for President. A long-time advocate for immigration reform, Gutierrez is now threatening his own party.

“We can stay home,” Gutierrez said in an interview with The Hill. “We can say, ‘You know what? There is a third option: We can refuse to participate.’ ”

Gutierrez is not a neophyte trying to make a name for himself, but a former cab driver who’s won handily in his last few elections. And still has dramatically low fundraising numbers – he raised less than $200,000 in 2006.

His arguments for immigration reform are more for the ears of Democrats.

“It is an answer to too many years of pain —mothers separated from their children, workers exploited and undermined security at the border— all caused at the hands of a broken immigration system,” he said in a December press release.

Crowley, on the other hand, knows that many Republicans see immigrants taking up more of their tax dollars – especially after Health Care Reform. So he crafts a different argument.

“A key element of this reform is requiring all undocumented immigrants to register, go through background checks, pay taxes, and study English in order to obtain legal status and be eligible to apply for U.S. citizenship,” Crowley wrote in December.

Crowley, who must be upset about the issue, has not publicly criticized any members of his party; and most likely won’t. But Gutierrez resembles Crowley’s district neighbor, Jose Serrano, in that they’ve been in office for a long time and both are Puerto Rican. Serrano, one of the few Democrats who voted against the financial bailout and also raises little campaign money, and Gutierrez have nothing to lose. Already widely popular in their districts, going against their party will not lose them any money or future elections.

Given Crowley’s track record of seeking out leadership positions, he probably has higher aspirations and the cash to make them happen. He’s already raised $3 millionin campaign contributions, far exceeding the House average. With President Obama planning federal immigration reform legislation, Crowley will wait for the political storm-of-the-week to pass before speaking up.

NY's #1 export….Diamonds??

Can you find anything in your office/room/wherever you are right now that has that little gold sticker that says “Made in the USA” on it? I remember peeling it off sometimes as a kid, but haven’t seen one lately.

I spent a while looking for it in my apartment, and couldn’t find one. Instead, I got Doc Martens made in Thailand, a camera made in Japan, a Samsung TV made in Tijuana, Mexico (who knew), and my Macbook Pro was designed in the U.S., but made in China.

For now, my apartment is Made-in-the-U.S.A.-less. Wait, found one, a saltshaker made in the U.S. – but it’s Mediterranean Sea salt, damn.

President Obama said he wants to double exports in the next five years and that this move will create 2 million jobs – quite a goal for a country that has a $39.7 million trade deficit, as of February 2010.

Joseph Crowley is trying to do his part. He hosted a seminar last week for business leaders from the Bronx and Queens to help them learn more about how the Federal government can assist them in exporting their goods.

“By opening up new markets to American goods and services, we will help U.S. businesses increase their bottom line and hire new workers,” he said.

Here’s part of Crowley’s Press Release:

Recent statistics compiled by the Department of Commerce show that exports are an important part of New York’s economy. In 2007, a total of 27,329 companies exported goods from New York locations, the third-highest number among the 50 states. But what percent of what they sold was exported?

More than one-fifth (20.9 percent) of all manufacturing workers in New York depend on exports for their jobs. How much do they depend? Are there companies whose livelihood depends on exports?

The number 1 export out of New York: diamonds. Yeah, I know, who knew.

Mike Mandel, an economist and journalist, doesn’t quite believe diamonds should count as real exports. Most likely, those diamonds are transported here.  A New York firm designs and cuts them, and then re-exports them.

Number 2 is drawings and paintings by hand – that makes a little more sense, number 3, jewelry parts and other precious metals. Those 3 add up to 25% of New York State exports.

The rest of the exports are an amalgam of engine parts, antiques, and digital processing units. Here’s the list of the top 25.

I don’t think the Bronx and Queens are producing much of those, but I could be wrong – I’m talking with someone from the Mayor’s office tomorrow.

This could be a good thing for growth in the Bronx and Queens, maybe there’s a market to be made. But there’s a reason why just about everything in my apartment was made somewhere else. It’s too expensive to pay people here.

I could be wrong, but it seems a few businesses here can export some products – there’s actually one commercial aviation facility in the Bronx, APD. Crowley is in tune with Obama’s message, but it might be a stretch for his district.

Health Reform May Split Heavily Democratic District

Protesters hurled racial epithets, spit at, and heckled Democratic congressmen who walked with linked arms to the Capitol from their office buildings Sunday, according to the Washington Post.

Hannah Rappleye, a freelance photographer, who was just snapping pictures of the demonstrations, had to wrestle her camera away from a tea party protester.  “I just got out of there,” she said.

Health reform passed but now “crossing the aisle” will get tougher. It passed but also has torn apart whatever social fabric or a sense of civility lay between Democrats and Republicans. This us-or-them mentality between parties seems to reach its apex each week.

Some members of Joseph Crowley’s district, which covers the Bronx and Queens, a region that votes heavily Democratic, are vowing to unseat the six-term Congressman on this issue.

Bob Diamond, speaking for the Committee to Save Medicare, said, “We’re going to meet with Congressman Crowley at his Throggs Neck office to let him know, in no uncertain terms, that we will work against his reelection if he votes for legislation that will destroy our freedoms and our way of life as American citizens,” told the Bronx News Net before Sunday’s vote.

This tension has given rise to “extremists” like Oath takers – a group even to the right of Tea partiers. These are members of the military who say are willing to fight against the government to protect the constitution from people trying to destroy it.

The last 14 months have created a more polarized America. Obama’s push to the center-left, might have created a new divide.

Crowley's Self-Criticism Leaves Little Else to be Said

George W. Bush’s inability to admit fault at a press conference in 2004 didn’t win him much compassion from voters. Oliver Stone’s movie, “W,” mocked the awkward moment, where the ex-president couldn’t come up with one mistake he made since 9/11.

Bush garnered a reputation as being too stubborn to own up to his mistakes. For politicians who can take responsibility, it can help soften the blow of criticism.

Joseph Crowley admitted fault for the delay in reconstruction of the World Trade Center buildings on Monday. In straightforward language, Crowley criticized his actions as well as those of other New York Politicians.

“Many of us on this stage have let you down,” said Crowley of the project to the Examiner.  “There’s enough blame to go around and I take responsibility as well, because nine years ago when I was told it would be built I assumed like everyone else that it would happen. I no longer assume anything.  And from here on out I take no promises to bed.  Along the line I’ve let you down; we’ve let you down. We’ve let this city down and we’ve let this country down.”

A far cry from politicians’ favorite, “mistakes were made,” Crowley’s political acumen elicits empathy from constituents. By being your biggest critic, it makes getting the same criticism from opponents seem redundant. Plus, it’s hard to imagine someone saying, “God, what a jerk, he totally screwed up, knows it and apologized for it.”

Crowley Banks on Foreigners

Outside Parkchester Train Station
Outside Parkchester Train Station

On blustery days, wind pushes trash up against the fences around the Parkchester subway stop in the Bronx. A “Chickenfest” restaurant, an off-track betting center, and a dry cleaners circle this express stop off the 6 train.

For outsiders, the southeast Bronx is seldom a final destination – its a place to drive through, rather than to drive to. Although crime has been down for much of the decade, the Bronx still has stretches of run-down, forgotten-about blocks.

Rep. Joe Crowley’s 7th district straddles much of the southeast Bronx and chunk of northern Queens. Besides $10 in tolls, quality of life separates the two boroughs. Queens residents are the happiest New Yorkers at 51 percent and Bronxites the least happy at 24 percent, according to the Citizens Committee for New York.

The number of defunct buildings in the Bronx might find some investors if the Real Estate Revitalization Act passes. The bill, sponsored by Crowley, will reduce the amount of taxes foreign investors pay for American real estate.

The Foreign Investment Real Estate Property Tax, passed in 1980, includes capital gains taxes as high as 55 percent – these taxes are generally applied to sales on property, stocks and bonds. For example, if a foreign investor buys and sells Google stock, they don’t pay taxes in America. But if an investor buys real estate investment trust (REIT) shares, they pay taxes in America, according to this CNNMoney.com article.

An abandoned foundation on White Plains road and Seward Ave
An abandoned foundation on White Plains road and Seward Ave

If Crowley’s bill passes, he may score some points with Republicans for advocating for a tax cut – albeit for foreigners. But Democrats may not be too fond of foreign investors competing with American buyers.

Since Americans aren’t buying up this property – and don’t have to pay any foreign taxes – why would foreigners think it’s a wise investment anyway?

"Big I" Gets Crowley to Speak at Lobbying Week

Big Insurance or “Big I” has been busy. They’ve already lobbied Washington with tons of money against health care reform. On March 4th, insurance agents will shake hands with members of Congress as part of a week long conference at our nation’s capital.

Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (IIABA) booked Rep. Joseph Crowley (D-N.Y.) for their annual “Big I” Day, where over a thousand members go to Capitol Hill to discuss issues at the “most effective insurance industry legislative event of its kind,” according to the associations press release.

Insurance companies are the leading contributor to Crowley’s campaign, making up $70,000 in 2009-2010, according to Opensecrets.org. Crowley sits on the Ways and Means Committee, so it’s not a surprise for insurance companies to try and court him. The committee is the chief tax-writing group of the House of Representatives, which also has some jurisdiction over social security, medicare and unemployment benefits.

But Crowley is still an advocate for health care reform. Back in August, while lobbyists contributed more $1.4 million to try and sway Congress from reform, Crowley started an interactive health care forum on his website. He recently voted for the Health Insurance Industry Fair Competition Act, which repealed antitrust protections from the health insurance industry. It passed by a landslide vote – 406 to 19.

Even with these contributions, Crowley continues to vote for liberal causes. The National Journal ranks him as more liberal than 89 percent of his peers. So, maybe “Big I” donates to Crowley because they see him as a future investment…?

Crowley Takes Advantage of Monserrate's Scandal

When Hiram Monserrate was convicted of a misdemeanor in October, Joseph Crowley led the call to oust Monserrate from his state senate seat, according to this Queens Gazette article. Crowley got his wish. The state senate kicked Monserrate out of office earlier this month. On a side note, Monserrate is actually running in the March 16 special election – he even stole Obama’s “Yes We Can” slogan.

Crowley’s move is more than getting the “bad guy” out of office. Crowley and Monserrate have had their differences in the past. In 2007, Crowley, the chairman of the Queens Democratic Party, did not invite Monserrate and Jose Peralta to an event honoring Malcolm Smith, the temporary President of the New York State legislature.

Monserrate voiced his concerns:

“I would like to be part of the host committee, but I was never asked,” Monserrate told the New York Daily News. “But the important thing is not the invitation itself but what it reveals. They don’t want to have anything to do with me or Peralta.”

Such public criticism couldn’t have sat well with Crowley. Peralta wasn’t as vocal as Monserrate, choosing just to note that he and Monserrate have never been chosen to host any Queens Democrat events. His decision seems to have kept him in good favor – Crowley now backs him for Monserrate’s seat.

The Daily News article added:

“Some Queens Democrats said, off the record, that the Monserrate slight is a product of the inordinate amount of power “the old guard” still holds over the Queens Democratic organization.”

Also, Monserrate and Pedro Espada Jr. voted against the Democratic Party last summer. The vote brought the New York legislature to a standstill. It seems Monserrate has run up against the established power, while Peralta has gone along with the status quo in Queens, and it may be paying off.

Crowley Leads Way for Immigration Reform

In a recent article by the National Journal, Joseph Crowley was named as one of five up-and-coming House Democrats. “They form a second tier of leaders-in-training who could be in line to take over when their top party chiefs either retire or are forced out,” according to the article.

The article also called Crowley the go-to person for immigration reform. Back in September, Crowley, along with 111 House Democrats, wrote a letter to President Obama asking to reform immigration. Obama gave a speech last year on June 25 asking for reform, but the issue hasn’t moved much since then.

The letter detailed elements of reform. Undocumented immigrants would register, go through background checks, pay taxes, study English in order to apply for legal status, and then eventually apply for citizenship. As chairman of the New Democrat Coalition – a pro-business, moderate group – Crowley proposes that taxing immigrants could be be way to generate revenue for the state and provide benefits for those contributing to the workforce.

More than 60 percent of Crowley’s district speaks a language other than English at home, and 40 percent of the population are foreign-born, according to the Almanac on American Politics. So, Crowley should have constituent support for immigration reform.

But his interest in immigration may also stem from a personal connection – his mother. She emigrated from Northern Ireland as a child, according to whorunsgov.com. Given that Crowley has sought leadership roles throughout his career, it seems likely he will run for a more prominent office in the future. So, he must think that reform should add political points in New York.