nadler

Health care victory, health care defeat

graf_map_REVAt 10am on Friday, April 9, the emergency room at St. Vincent’s Hospital stopped taking patients as the institution prepared to shut its doors and file bankruptcy. The battle to save St. Vincent’s has been one of the highest profile issues in Congressman Nadler’s district.

“After a tremendous effort by all stakeholders to save the hospital as an acute care facility, it has become clear that this option is not viable due to the economic realities facing the hospital,” Nadler said in a press release after hospital officials announced their decision.

St. Vincent’s closing leaves the west side of lower Manhattan empty of emergency room and inpatient care. The closest comparable care facility–Bellevue Hospital–is two miles away. Local activists, elected officials and the hospital itself have kept the financially troubled, privately-run hospital on life support for months, hoping to find a permanent solution to keep the 50,000-ER-patients-a-year facility from closing.

The blow to Nadler’s district–however anticipated–comes just weeks after the triumphant passage of health care reform in Washington. Nadler has been in-district defending the bill, according to the West Side Spirit. Unlike much of what cable news reports, Nadler’s constituents were putting the congressman on the defensive for not going far enough with the legislation.

Still, the fact now remains, despite the congressman’s support, his district is now down a major medical facility. He has promised to work to have an adequate medical facility in the West Village. St. Vincent’s is one of a number of hospitals in the city that have shut their doors over the past decade. Even if health care reform delivers for New Yorkers, residents of the West Side will now have a harder time finding it.

Moynihan and Coney Island Announcements in Nadler's Disrict

Rendering of the Moynhian Station interior (Photo The Related Cos.)
Rendering of the Moynihan Station interior (Image: The Related Cos.)

The 8th Congressional district saw two major announcements yesterday.

First, Sen. Schumer announced that just over $83 million in federal stimulus funds have been secured to convert the iconic Farley post office on 33rd Street and 8th Avenue into the long-envisioned, often-RIP’d Moynihan Station. The new transit hub will connect to Penn Station next door and provide Amtrak with additional space.

From Crain’s:

The federal grant means there is now enough money to start the first phase, which will cost about $220 million and take five to six years to complete. It includes expanding access to the various train tracks, creating two new entrances to the Farley building, and adding elevators, stairs and escalators.

“We’ve got the money now let’s get to work,” said Mr. Schumer, in a statement. “The best way to get New York’s economy moving again is to keep building, and the best project to get things started is Moynihan Station.”

Rep Nadler has long supported the project and has historically pushed for area rail projects, most notably the controversially Cross-Harbor Rail Tunnel.

While Sen. Schumer braved the snow to deliver the news, Rep. Nadler was with Mayor Bloomberg at the New York Aquarium in Coney Island to unveil new amusement park plans for the historic area. By Memorial Day of this year “Luna Park” is set to open with 19 new rides and hundreds of new jobs. The following summer, “Scream Zone” will add, according to the press release, “additional attractions, including two custom roller coasters, a human slingshot ride, and go-karts.”

The developer, Central Amusement International, has said it will invest $30 million into the project, with the city kicking

Future sites of Luna Park and Scream Zone (Image courtesy of Mayor's office)
Future sites of Luna Park and Scream Zone (Image courtesy of Mayor's office)

in $6.6 million in “site preparation and basic infrastructure.” Recently rezoned, an additional 5,000 new housing units and expanded retail opportunities are planned to be built in Coney Island soon.

Rep. Nadler has requested millions of dollars in appropriation funds for the area. These projects include shore protection work through the Army Corps of Engineers and improving the the 9th floor of Coney Island Hospital.

“It’s been a long time coming,” Nadler said at the press conference yesterday. “I cannot remember a time when we weren’t talking about revitalizing the amusement area at Coney Island.

“This really should be a rebirth of this area. A rebirth that involves, as was said, no relocation, no dislocation. Only constructive endeavors.”

While the degree of “rebirth” needed in the area is debatable (Coney Island, to some, appeared to be doing just fine revitalizing itself), Rep. Nadler’s cooperative stance with the mayor over Coney Island is in stark contrast to the West Side Stadium fight a few years ago.

Still, it will remain to be seen if — and when — these two major projects meet their expectations.