Author Archives: Joseph Tacopino

Campaign Cash on Staten Island

allegretti1020jpg-30d67cee9b3df714_medium
Mike Allegretti

McMahon’s got the name and the dough.

In his 2010 reelection bid Mike McMahon has the advantage of political tenure and the mountain of cash that comes with incumbency.

His two potential opponents are relatively unknown and frantically shaking hands and taking donations across the borough.

Mike Grimm is a former FBI agent and Gulf War veteran. His first run for office is fueled by a passion for conservative principles and a urge to uproot the current regime in Congress.

“I believe our country is on a very dangerous path,” Grimm told me last week, over the phone. “People are angry. People are more conservative here and they are not for a Nancy Pelosi agenda.”

Mike Allegretti is a relatively young former Brooklynite and political staffer who is making a name for himself in his new home, out on the borough of Staten Island.

“This is a values-based community,” Allegretti said. “I believe McMahon is a political member of Congress. With him people come second, politics comes first.”

While there are slight shades of difference between these political neophytes, their biggest challenge is to raise awareness, and money, on a borough very much neglected by Manhattan media — except, of course, when the ferry crashes.

As election day gets closer McMahon’s campaign will unlock the vault and let that ocean of cash flood Staten Island with poltical ads. And it is unclear whether the Republican candidates will sink or swim.

Cash on Hand(according to OpenSecrets.org)

Bay Ridge, John Travolta, Allegretti, and Me

Saturday-Night-Fever_John-Travolta_white-suit-train.bmp-1The 1977 film Saturday Night Fever immortalized the working class Italian-Americans of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. The movie not only made an impact on bell bottoms, and disco culture but came to symbolize the middle class outer borough experience in New York City.

The scrappy, foul-mouthed, sexpot played by John Travolta was the uncanny personification of both alpha-male and arrogant jackoff at the same exact time.

Another Italian from Bay Ridge is Michael Allegretti, one of Congressman Mike McMahon’s potential Republican opponents in the 2010 election.

Though demographics have changed in Bay Ridge, the area has been unmistakably linked to the borough of Staten Island ever since the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge opened in 1964.

I myself was born in Bay Ridge in 1979, around the same time that the Bee Gees coaxed John Travolta onto the dance floor.

I moved to Staten Island with my parents as a small child and it seems that a large percentage of the neighborhood came with us.

While population has exploded in all of Staten Island’s three community districts (especially the southern portion) the population for Bay Ridge and its neighboring Dyker Heights decreased by 7 percent in the ’80s, according to census figures.

Census figures also show that Staten Island in 64 percent Italian-American: John Travolta with receding hairline, a tracksuit, and three kids in grade school.

Still, the association with their former Bay Rige neighborrhood runs deep, deeper perhaps than the one with the boot-shaped penninsula their ancestors emigrated from. Islanders speak with a reverence for the RR Train and Woolworth’s as if it were their home country.

The truly off-the-boat Italians came to this country in turn-of the-century (last century), so these Italian-Americans are three, or four, generations removed.

Where does that leave Mike Allegretti in the 13th District? Bay Ridge native, Richmond county transplant, son of a successful small businessman, and, most importantly, Italian.

I’d say he’s right at home.

St. George Protects the Island from Dragons

st_george_slayingYesterday was St. George’s Day, a European holiday devoted to the legend of St. George slaying a dragon.

So the Staten Island neighborhood of St. George decided to join in on the fun and hold an art and music fair in a local park.

Bands performed in Tompkinsville Square, a short walk from the Staten Island Ferry. Artists displayed paintings and photographs, kids did arts & crafts, tree-huggers dressed as fairies and distributed seed bombs to promote Earth Day.

All this in a park once, and intermittently still, populated by drunks, crackheads, methadone patients, and welfare recipients from the food stamp office right across the street.

Like most of New York City, crime has decreased since the Giuliani administration, and the area is relatively safer than it once was.

The St. George neighborhood, home to the Staten Island Ferry, is the Island’s northernmost point, the progressive shore: an artist enclave, a commuter haven, a place which stands as Staten Island’s best opportunity to become a vibrant and dynamic piece of New York City, instead of the insulated Jersey Shore mall-culture.

This locale, close to Manhattan and Brooklyn, is the previous city council district of now-Congressman Mike McMahon and represents a more Manhattan-centric liberalism than the rest of the boro.

The North Shore is also the home to Staten Island’s first African-American elected official as well as the first openly gay pol.

Another local politician, State Senator Diane Savino (D – SI and Brooklyn), made a passionate plea advocating gay marriage in the New York State last year.

But, again, Sen. Savino represents the North Shore, and this is the exception to the norm on the Island.

The South Shore is conservative in nature and not particularly welcome to outsiders. They would not exactly embrace the idea of an openly gay person in theory, never mind as an elected official. And if they tolerate African-Americans, they certainly don’t want them living in their gated community.

In a Slate.com piece, Jonah Weiner (a former St, George resident) tried to explain the Island’s intransigence toward the rest of the city.

Weiner likened the New York Harbor, which separates the aforementioned boroughs, to a moat that protects a majestic land from the miscreants.

What side that majestic land is on, however, depends on whom you ask, according to Weiner.

I would argue that an Islanders perception of the moat depends more upon where they live.

The North Shore is a diverse environment, a place where once-Councilmen McMahon could practice his centrist democratic ideals with apparent impunity from the Island’s more conservative, moat-friendly areas. Here, the castle is a ferry ride away.

To the Islanders on the Southern shores, in their heavily-fortified McMansions, St. George the neighborhood, like the patron saint himself, is their protective barricade against the potential ‘dragons’ that may lurk on the other side of the harbor in the dirty, graffiti-infested streets they left in the ’70s to join the kingdom of Richmond County.

No Country for Obama

P1-AS056_Gopspl_G_20091015165914It’s not quite an uphill battle, but with his reelection bid Mike McMahon faces a kind of strange paradox:

How does he remain true to the centrist Democratic principles that made him quite successful as a city councilman on the North Shore, while at the same time appeasing the rest of the borough, which was so eloquently described to us on Fox last week as “not Obama country?”

This negotiation will play itself out over the next seven months, but it leaves the rest of New York City wondering: Why is Staten Island not “Obama country?”

We spoke a little last week about the geographic and cultural isolation of the borough, the overwhelming preponderance of white people on the South Shore, and a particularly vehement hatred for liberal, black politicians (Debi Rose, Al Sharpton, President Obama, Charlie Rangel).

Another question to ask might be: Where do these people get their information from?

Well, primarily Fox News.

Staten Islanders will proudly tell you that they get all their right-wing propaganda from Fox.

“I watch Fox News every night,” a small business owner told me in the heat of the health care debate.

This may seem innocent enough but he wore it like a badge of honor. As if to say, “I know exactly what is going on with this ‘socialist health care scam,’ because I follow it very closely — on Fox News.”

The other trusted news source on Staten Island is it’s only local paper, the tragically sinking ship known as the Staten Island Advance, and its sister site SILive.com.

SILive reposts the Advance ‘news’ and its comment threads are usually littered with right-wing rants that have nothing to do with the substance of said news.

Here’s an enlightening remark about a piece regarding North Shore City Councilwoman, and the Island’s first black politician, Debi Rose.

Picture 1
This is just anonymous online posters, they are not representative of much.

But I wonder if we could somehow poll these people, maybe find out, say, what political fringe they are most associated with.

Oh wait look, they voted on their favorite story of 2009.

Picture 3Wow, I guess those racist trolls voted on the Tea Party — just an educated guess.

As far as the paper is concerned, the editorial board is, at times, rabidly right-wing.

Here a recent selection from April 13 by Daniel Leddy, a man whose moral compass swings more frequently then a ’70s leisure suit.

The piece is called “A leftist agenda drives smear campaign against Pope Benedict.”

“…the New York Times, which has been spearheading the shameless defamation of Pope Benedict XVI, is a demonstrably and obsessively anti-Catholic publication. Facing bankruptcy and shedding all but the thinnest disguise of responsible journalism, the newspaper struggles to survive by intensifying its long-standing prostitution for left-wing causes.”

Alright, the column argues that the pederasts in the Catholic church are completely not at fault here. (NAMBLA would be proud of this column.) It is all the fault of the New York Times and their “prostitution of left wing causes.” OK…

Well, this is opinion right, the Advance does have ‘straight news.’

A week after the President signed his historic health care reform bill Staten Islanders were comforted to find this piece of ‘news’ in their morning papers:

‘Are there enough doctors in the house?’

“But if all of Staten Island’s 49,000-plus uninsured adults get insurance and start going to the doctor more often,” the newspaper warned, “there may not be enough primary-care physicians here to serve them.”

Sound the alarm bells.

Never mind that Obama’s health care overhaul will dramatically improve the lives of millions who currently do not have insurance. The real issue here is that these uninsured people, most likely poor, and probably black, will be flooding the waiting room at MY doctor’s office.

It’s not surprised that the paper would play this kind of ‘class warfare’ card on dawn of a new age of health care reform. It’s exactly the kind of alarmist bullshit that Staten Islanders have come to expect from their news sources.

The Island, or most of it, has become a vapid echo chamber of right-wing talking points. A two-way dialogue between the ‘man-on-the-street’ or the Tea Party and the Island establishment, or the Richmond County Country Club.

Unless this cycle ends, it won’t become Obama country any time soon.

Why is Staten Island not 'Obama country'?

ross001-manly-and-frank-santarpiaIt must have sounded strange to New York City residents who woke up last week and heard a local wanna-be politician bash the Democratic congress on a Fox 5 morning show. But that’s exactly what they got when Staten Island’s Republican challenger to Mike McMahon made an appearance on the program.

Mike Grimm, former FBI stooge and Tea Party panderer, appeared on the show and gave an eloquent alternative to the Island’s current rep on Capital Hill.

The contender was more subdued and pragmatic then the acerbic letters that come out of his press apparatus.

His biggest bullshit moment cam when he was asked why Staten Island id so different politically from the rest of the city or “Obama country” as the host called it:

“I think it’s a few things. It’s the highest concentration of veterans, It’s the highest concentration of small business owners, it’s the highest concentration of Italian Americans.”

Really, where does he get these numbers from? I had no idea there were more veterans in Staten Island then, say, Queens, or the South Bronx. Italian-Americans? Yeah, I’ll give you that. But small business owners? More small businesses or a “higher concentration” whatever that means, then Manhattan? Brooklyn? Nah, don’t think so.?

So why is Staten Island really more politically right-leaning than the rest of the city?

It’s geographically isolated from the other four boros. The only way to get off the island and into “Obama country” is the 25-minute excursion of the Staten Island Ferry and the Verrazano-Narrows bridge to Brooklyn. On the southern tip of the island, is a neighborhood called Tottenville, which is so close to New Jersey that the boro’s growing deer population is rumored to swim across the Arthur Kill on to Tottenville’s shores. If the deer were to take the train however, they would have a 45-minute ride just to get to the ferry from those beaches.

And there’s all those white people. Census estimates put some South Shore neighborhoods at 75 to 80 percent white.  Not that this should matter. But the island’s politically active have a particular disgust for black politicians, hence the Staten Island Tea Party and references to the Island first black elected official as an “ugly low life” who reminds them of “the old show Mr. Ed.”

This is why Staten Island is not “Obama country.” It has nothing do to with Grimm’s erroneous assertion that we have more small businesses here.

Staten Island says 'no' to health reform

Staten Island’s Rep. Mike McMahon was the only “No” vote on health care reform out of the New York City delegation.

In a sense he gave the district exactly what they wanted: blind obstruction.

It’s no surprise that most of the island, although grossly misinformed, is decidedly against the president’s health care initiative — or any other initiative he has for that matter.

I’ve done some reporting on this issue in the past and the feelings from the mid-island business community was generally weary of this elusive health care plan.

Here is a sampling for Sept 09:

“My husband has his own business and he pays $2,000 a month for insurance. We’re hurting but I do have three kids. I don’t know what I’m going to get (if reform passes).”

– Pat Siringo, clerk at Uniquely Yours

“It’s not the cheapest but at least I have insurance. I am concerned about the effect this plan will have on seniors. I don’t want any more change; I’ve had enough change.”

-Lorraine Graziano, owner of S I Quick Print.

“My wife had to get a job at (Staten Island University) Hospital so I could get health care. I went for two years without insurance. But, if you work 20 years to get to a certain point with your business why should you be penalized (with higher taxes). It’s not right, I hope it doesn’t pass.”

-Michael DiGuido, owner of The Animal Pantry.

“He won’t vote for it, and it won’t pass. Financially it doesn’t make any sense. Staten Island is a conservative place in general. Staten Island can take care of itself.”
-Warren Crapo owner Crapo Realty

Every single business owner complained about the rising costs of health care. However, every single business owner was strongly against health care reform.

Is there a disconnect here? Where are they getting their info? Fox News? The Advance? The Marketeer?

By Tuesday, the media was sniping at McMahon from every angle.

The NY Daily News claimed that the White House was upset with McMahon’s intransigence.

The local paper spoke to a potential primary challenger, who had lost to McMahon in ’08.

Meanwhile McMahon’s opponents were unsheathing their right-wing rhetoric.

“It is a very sad day for all Americans when bribery and backroom deals beat the will of the people,” Mike Grimm said in a press release.

The other Mike, Allegretti, went to the NY Post to air his grievances

But what about the Island’s conservative base? They must be on McMahon’s side now right?

“As long as the congressman has a ‘D’ next to his name, he will be part of the problem in perpetuating the Pelosi Congress,” said Santarpia, the leader of Staten Island’s Tea Party, to the Staten Island Advance.

Looks like McMahon can’t please anybody.

GOP Candidates Battle it out on Staten Island

boxersAre you ready to rumble?

Well I hope not because you’ll be extremely disappointed.

The two Republican challengers to Congressman Mike McMahon faced off in a “debate” last week in the posh environs of the Hilton Garden Inn on Staten Island, and the affair was the exact claptrap you’d expect from a couple of “Island” Republicans.

It was Mike Grimm, the fiery Gulf War veteran, against Mike Allegretti, the wonder boy transplant from Brooklyn. Here are some observations:

1. Look at all those white people! We know Staten Island is more then 70 percent white according to census estimates, but how about a little diversity?  Political involvement on Staten Island doesn’t just occur in elite social clubs. Oh, wait, it does.

2. On health care reform Grimm starts off strong: railing against the “backdoor dealings” (btw, does he mean backroom, or is he talking about Rep. Massa?). Grimm quickly loses focus and his tirade devolves into a litany of talking points with a connect-the-dots relationship to the subject. “The Pharma, Unions, giveaways, the Louisiana Purchase” (huh?)

Bottom line: health care reform bad. Open up exchanges across state lines and cut taxes. That will fix everything!

3. Next up is wonder boy Allegretti. What’s his take on health care reform?

“[If] you wanna renovate your house you don’t knock it down. You renovate it and you continue living in it at the same time.”

Really? No shit, this is almost the same exact analogy that former Rep. Vito Fossella used during his half-assed attempt to make a public stance on the issue. Are these guys trading talking points like baseball cards? or do they have the same consultant? Maybe Allegretti has a family on the side as well. Probably not, just saying.

3. Next: How do we create jobs?

Believe it or not they both agree: cut taxes. Ronald Reagan’s cold dead body and trickle down economics lives on in the swank hotel lobbies of Staten Island.

4. Is global warming real?

Wait, this is a serious question? As soon as I start to feel bad for ripping on you guys you allude to the ridiculous, scientifically unsound position that global warming doesn’t exist.

Grimm: the jury is still out.

Props to Allegretti for admitting that global warming is in fact real and even if it’s not “what the heck do we do when the oil runs out and the coal runs out?” Great question. I’d love to hear Grimm’s response. Drill, baby drill??

5. They both hate abortion: no surprise.

6. On foreign policy, Allegretti sounds well-versed, tackling the issue of Yemeni terror groups and the threat of radical Islam in the Arabian peninsula.

In summary, Allegretti seems like a fairly nuanced conservative. One who can see both sides of an issue and come out with a well-informed position. Grimm seems like an ideologue. Unfortunately for Allegretti, the decision-making process will most likely take place in stuffy forums like this one rather than among ordinary Joe-six packs of Staten Island.

Staten Island and the Armenian Genocide

armenc7135The Armenian Genocide was the systematic slaughter of 1.5 million residents of the Ottoman empire in a campaign that lasted from 1915 to 1923.

On Thursday the House Foreign Affairs Committee narrowly approved a resolution that would acknowledge the genocide despite of a last-ditch effort by the Obama administration to stop the initiative claiming it could damage relations with Turkey.

Mike McMahon voted against the measure which passed 23-22.

“Instead of looking backwards to the turn of the 20th century, we need to look forward in the 21st century,” McMahon said in a press release.

Mike Allegretti, one of McMahon’s Republican challengers in the 2010 congressional race, decided to make a stand on the issue:

“I urge the members of the House Foreign Relations to stand-up and recognize the genocide which took place between 1915-1923,” Allegretti stated in a press release. “It is unspeakable that one and a half million Armenians lost their lives in an effort to erase them from their homeland. Passage of this resolution would be a positive step for the region.”

So Allegretti has staked his position on the issue. Is this smart politics, humanitarian empathy, misguided pandering to the Armenian lobby, knee-jerk opposition?

Let’s take a look at the demographics of the district:

Census population estimates for Staten Island place white residents at about 71 percent of the Island, with 9 percent black, 12 percent Hispanic, and 5.6 percent Asian. Under the designation “some other race” stands at 0.2 percent – maybe a sliver of that is Allegretti’s Armenian constituency.

There is no doubt that the unspeakable crimes from almost a century ago need to be recognized and the victims of these crimes deserve some sort of restitution. But a congressional measure on this issue is unnecessary or, worse, detrimental to US interests abroad.

In addition, the issue of the Armenian genocide is not even vaguely on the legislative radar for the vast majority of Staten Islanders, who are plagued with paltry public transportation and congested highways among other concerns about the economy and the prospect of another terrorist attack in NYC.

If Allegretti wants to make the Armenian issue even a minor focus of his campaign I’d wish him the best of luck, there’s always a position waiting for him at Bayside Fuel Oil.

Mikey in the middle

gop_balancing_act23 There is now proof that the congressman from Staten Island is not the partisan hack his critics have tarred him as.

According to a report by National Journal, Congressman Mike McMahon was rated the 211th most conservative member of the House and 219 among liberals — right smack in the middle of the 435-member chamber.

His campaign has seized on the news, touting it on their Web site and Facebook account. But they still have work to do.

The campaign, fledgling as it may be (the elections is eight months away) has to create a narrative. They need to sell McMahon as something Islanders can embrace and root for. He needs to be “one of them.”

In case no one has noticed, Staten Island is uniquely isolated from the rest of New York City, and for that matter, the entire state. There are three bridges connecting the island to New Jersey but only one that leads to Brooklyn; and Manhattan, you need to take the ferry to go there.

People there are distrustful of outsiders (sorry Allegretti), independent in the traditional sense, and, maybe at times, a little paranoid.

“Staten Island is a conservative place, we could take care of ourselves,” Warren Crapo owner of Crapo Realty told me back in September when I interviewed business owners in anticipation of the House health care vote.

I haven’t heard too much from the campaign. I know they are busy, and let’s be honest, this isn’t the New York Times here, but most major publications will treat this race as a peripheral issue, a sidebar from the ‘other borough.’

So here’s my own narrative. A portrait of a non-partisan centrist:

Mike McMahon has rejected the scorched earth policy of D.C. and has devoted his Congressional career to working with other members of the House on issues vital to Staten Islanders. Mike is not concerned with latching himself to the latest political trend or being a lackey of the current Democratic regime. He has, and always will, put locals issues (small businesses, modernizing transportation, combating terrorism) in their proper place above nonsensical partisan point-scoring.

Maybe McMahon will get similar advice for the editorial pages of the Staten Island Advance: but I wouldn’t hold my breath.

Fighting fire with press releases

giuliani_trump_dragIn the nascent 2010 race from the 13th congressional seat in New York a major player has thrown his wig into the ring.

On Feb 19 Rudy Giuliani was scheduled to make a public endorsement of Republican candidate Mike Grimm on the steps of City Hall. 

That appearance was delayed by the unfortunate news that Bernard Kerik was convicted in an epic corruption case.

So instead of a choreographed theater in lower Manhattan, reporter’s got a press release:

“Michael Grimm has outstanding qualifications for public office.” said Giuliani. “As a U.S. Marine he served in combat for our county and then he continued to serve our country for 11 years as a Special Agent in the FBI.”

The City Hall announcement was also notable for its location.

While the 13th district covers the vast and pastoral lands of Staten Island (and Bay Ridge) Grimm chose to make this campaign-defining announcement in lower Manhattan.

From the start, it seems that Grimm has been running his campaign with a national bent.

He launched the campaign at the Hilton Garden Inn (a new luxurious hotel overlooking the former site of the Staten Island Dump) and immediately tied McMahon to the leadership in Congress, calling him a “faithful vote for the Pelosi liberal regime.”

McMahon is actually more of a “blue dog” who voted against the Democrat’s health care bill.

Grimm is also trying to capture the Tea Party magic by name-dropped Scott Brown.

“He ran for the right reasons,” Grimm told the Advance.

I’m sure he’d love to ride the Senator’s mudflaps all the way to Washington DC. But do Staten Islanders really care what happens in Boston?

The response from the McMahon’s campaign has been tepid. 

The office has recently hired consultant, Evan Stavisky, who cited McMahon’s devotion to “the district’s centrist values.”

McMahon will likely cite terrorism funding and the economy as issues that actually impact Islanders but he needs to step up his game before Grimm snags an endorsement from Sarah Palin.